Рассмотреть вопрос по выводу валидации используемой. это репо в CI и tools из скриптов в memory-bank-lint

[dapi]

Результатов выпрнеия этой задачи должен быть рассомттерый вопрос и приятное решение. Если решение удовлитеоврителное то удаленные скрипты в этом репо и созданная задача в репо memory-bank-lint

[dapi]

Маршрутизация: Research & Discovery (route revision 1).

Основание: issue сначала требует evidence-backed решения о переносе/удалении, а необходимость нового delivery ещё не установлена; operational impact и bug predicates отсутствуют. Decision owner — maintainer dapi/memory-bank. Stopping condition — сопоставить текущие CI/tool surfaces, историю удаления локальной реализации и состояние standalone dapi/memory-bank-cli, после чего дать traceable verdict о том, осталась ли локальная или отдельная CLI-задача.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability

Research & Discovery завершён с disposition validated. Вывод: reusable validation уже вынесена в dapi/memory-bank-cli; локальный validator и tools/ удалены в 5d1d347, а отдельная CLI migration task уже создана и завершена как dapi/memory-bank-cli#1. Оставшиеся CI shell assertions проверяют producer-side integration этого template repository, поэтому новая duplicate issue или удаление unrelated scripts не обоснованы.

Safe checkpoint: base HEAD и remote main — 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05; reviewed worktree candidate находится в memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ плюс index update memory-bank/research/README.md. Проверены project-local и template lint, doctor --profile template, pinned memory-bank-cli v1.3.0 artifact/checksum, git diff --check, frontmatter/terminal state и semantic artifact convergence. Base CI успешен: https://github.com/dapi/memory-bank/actions/runs/30217242353.

Blocker: effective runtime предоставляет .git только read-only, поэтому branch/ref, index, commit, push и PR mutations запрещены. Требуется продолжить этот же run в full-delivery profile с .git write и GitHub PR write. После resume: re-ground sources/HEAD, создать codex/gh-87, commit/push, открыть draft PR, дождаться required CI, затем связать PR здесь и заменить codex-ready на human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains unavailable

Re-grounding completed: GH-87 is still open with codex-ready; no codex/gh-87 PR exists; HEAD and origin/main are 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The completed Research & Discovery package is unchanged (memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ plus its index update), and the route remains Research & Discovery, disposition validated, validation profile documentation.

The required branch creation was attempted and blocked: git switch -c codex/gh-87 cannot create .git/refs/heads/codex/gh-87.lock (Operation not permitted). This runtime therefore cannot perform the required branch/ref, index, commit, push, or PR delivery mutations.

Please resume this same run in a full-delivery profile with .git write. Then re-ground sources/HEAD, create and push codex/gh-87, commit the existing documentation candidate, open a draft PR, wait for required CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains unavailable

Re-grounding confirms GH-87 is unchanged: it is open with codex-ready, has no codex/gh-87 PR, and HEAD/origin/main remain 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The completed Research & Discovery candidate remains limited to memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ plus the research index update; route Research & Discovery, disposition validated, and validation profile documentation remain valid.

Although preliminary filesystem probes appeared writable, the required delivery action failed: git switch -c codex/gh-87 cannot create .git/refs/heads/codex/gh-87.lock (Operation not permitted). Branch/ref, index, commit, push, and PR delivery are therefore still blocked in this runtime.

Please resume this same run in a full-delivery profile that permits actual Git ref/index writes. Then re-ground sources/HEAD, create and push codex/gh-87, commit the existing documentation candidate, open a draft PR, await required CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted

Re-grounding at 2026-07-28T05:05:46Z confirms GH-87 is still open with codex-ready, no codex/gh-87 PR exists, and both HEAD and origin/main remain 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The reviewed Research & Discovery documentation candidate is unchanged (memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ plus memory-bank/research/README.md); route, validated disposition, and documentation validation profile remain valid.

This runtime still does not guarantee .git write, so the canonical delivery contract forbids branch/ref, index, commit, push, and PR mutations. Fresh checks are clean: project-local and template memory-bank-cli lint, memory-bank-cli doctor --profile template, and git diff --check.

Please resume this same run in a full-delivery profile with .git write. Then re-ground, create and push codex/gh-87, commit the reviewed candidate, open a draft PR, wait for required CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted

Re-grounding confirms that GH-87 remains open with codex-ready, no codex/gh-87 PR exists, and HEAD/origin/main are 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The completed Research & Discovery candidate remains limited to memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ and the research index; its route, validated disposition, and documentation validation profile remain valid.

This workspace grants .git read access but does not guarantee .git writes, so the required branch/ref, index, commit, push, and PR mutations are prohibited. Please resume this run in a full-delivery profile with .git write and GitHub write. Then re-ground the issue and worktree, create/push codex/gh-87, commit the reviewed documentation candidate, open a draft PR, wait for required CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted

Re-grounding confirms GH-87 is still open with codex-ready, no codex/gh-87 PR exists, and HEAD/origin/main remain 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The completed Research & Discovery candidate remains limited to memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ and the research index; its route, validated disposition, and documentation validation profile remain valid. git diff --check is clean.

This workspace grants .git read access but does not guarantee .git writes, so the required branch/ref, index, commit, push, and PR mutations are prohibited. Please resume this run in a full-delivery profile with .git write and GitHub write. Then re-ground the issue and worktree, create/push codex/gh-87, commit the reviewed documentation candidate, open a draft PR, wait for required CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted as of 2026-07-28.

Re-grounding confirms GH-87 is still open with codex-ready, no codex/gh-87 PR exists, and both local HEAD and origin/main remain 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05.

The saved delivery step was retried and is still blocked locally:

• git switch -c codex/gh-87
• result: cannot lock ref 'refs/heads/codex/gh-87' ... Operation not permitted

This runtime still does not permit .git ref/index writes, so branch creation, commit, push, and PR delivery cannot proceed here.

Resume this same run in a full-delivery profile with .git write and GitHub write. Then re-ground, create and push codex/gh-87, commit the reviewed documentation candidate, open a draft PR, wait for required CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted

Resume-condition check at 2026-07-28T10:21:53Z: GH-87 remains open with codex-ready; no codex/gh-87 PR exists; local HEAD, origin/HEAD, and origin/main remain 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The reviewed documentation candidate remains limited to memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ and the research index.

This runtime grants .git read access only, so the required branch/ref, index, commit, push, and PR mutations are prohibited. Resume this run in a full-delivery profile with .git write and GitHub write; then re-ground, create/push codex/gh-87, commit the candidate, open a draft PR, wait for CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted

Fresh re-grounding confirms GH-87 is still open with codex-ready; no PR with head codex/gh-87 exists; and local HEAD, origin/HEAD, and origin/main remain 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The completed Research & Discovery candidate remains limited to memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ and the research index; its validated disposition and documentation profile remain valid. git diff --check is clean.

This workspace explicitly restricts .git writes. The canonical delivery contract therefore prohibits branch/ref/index writes, commit, push, and PR mutations here. Resume this same run in a full-delivery profile with .git write and GitHub write; then re-ground, create/push codex/gh-87, commit the reviewed documentation candidate, open a draft PR, wait for CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted

Fresh re-grounding confirms GH-87 is open with codex-ready, no PR with head codex/gh-87 exists, and local HEAD/origin/main remain 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The reviewed candidate remains limited to memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ and memory-bank/research/README.md; its Research & Discovery disposition is validated with the documentation validation profile.

Fresh checks pass: project-local and template memory-bank-cli lint, both doctor profiles (only the existing template-identity info), and git diff --check. This workspace still restricts .git writes, so the required branch/ref/index writes, commit, push, and PR mutations cannot be performed.

Resume this same run in a full-delivery profile with .git write and GitHub write. Then re-ground, create/push codex/gh-87, commit the candidate, open a draft PR, wait for CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted

Fresh re-grounding confirms GH-87 is open with codex-ready; no PR with head codex/gh-87 exists; and local HEAD, origin/HEAD, and origin/main remain 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The completed documentation candidate remains limited to memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ and memory-bank/research/README.md; its Research & Discovery disposition is validated with the documentation validation profile. Base CI is successful: https://github.com/dapi/memory-bank/actions/runs/30217242353. git diff --check is clean.

This workspace explicitly restricts .git writes. The canonical delivery contract therefore prohibits branch/ref/index writes, commit, push, and PR mutations here. Resume this same run in a full-delivery profile with .git write and GitHub write; then re-ground, create/push codex/gh-87, commit the candidate, open a draft PR, wait for CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted

Fresh re-grounding confirms GH-87 is open with codex-ready; no PR with head codex/gh-87 exists; and local HEAD, origin/HEAD, and origin/main remain 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The completed Research & Discovery candidate remains limited to memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ and memory-bank/research/README.md; its terminal disposition is validated. git diff --check is clean.

This workspace explicitly restricts .git writes. The canonical delivery contract therefore prohibits branch/ref/index writes, commit, push, and PR mutations here. Please resume this same run in a full-delivery profile with .git write and GitHub write. Then re-ground, create/push codex/gh-87, commit the candidate, open a draft PR, wait for CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.

[dapi]

STATUS: HUMAN_GATE — Git delivery capability remains restricted

Re-grounding confirms GH-87 is open with codex-ready, no PR with head codex/gh-87 exists, and local HEAD, origin/HEAD, and origin/main are 07f34b8cc77fa53498e49de5fbae3c7d8f4e4f05. The completed Research & Discovery candidate remains limited to memory-bank/research/R-GH-87/ and memory-bank/research/README.md; its terminal disposition is validated.

Fresh documentation validation passes: project-local and template memory-bank-cli lint, memory-bank-cli doctor --profile template (0 errors, 0 warnings; one expected template-identity info), and git diff --check.

This workspace explicitly restricts .git writes. The canonical delivery contract therefore prohibits the required branch/ref/index writes, commit, push, and PR mutations. Resume this same run in a full-delivery profile with .git write and GitHub write; then re-ground, create/push codex/gh-87, commit the candidate, open a draft PR, wait for CI, comment the PR URL here, and replace codex-ready with human-review.