Project report (PDF) · Research decision and evidence limits
Euro Stoxx quote-holdout price RMSE is 34.18% below SSVI but only 0.93% below ordinary H1; whole-expiry RMSE is 46.81% worse than SSVI. On known truth, mean volatility RMSE is 0.09679 versus SSVI 0.04096; five of ten draws favour the full operator.
Research decision: Resolve numerical optimisation and recovery instability before claiming benefit from the spatial potentials.
Does a spatially varying regularisation penalty improve option pricing and local-volatility recovery beyond standard smoothness controls?
Option prices reveal information about volatility, but a finite set of noisy quotes does not uniquely determine an entire surface. A model can match those quotes while producing unstable behaviour between them. This research project investigates a quantum-mechanics-inspired regulariser that controls both how a fitted correction varies and where it is allowed to depart from a reference surface.
The specific modelling choice is a Schrödinger-type quadratic energy: a smoothness term plays the role of kinetic energy, while a spatial potential penalises corrections more strongly where quotes are sparse or strikes are far from the money. I implement that energy inside a Dupire PDE calibration, derive a conditional Lipschitz stability bound, and test whether the added structure improves pricing and volatility recovery against simpler penalties.
Theory and derivations · Comparison with existing research · Results · Full audit report
Regularisation is already central to local-volatility calibration. The research question here concerns the particular spatial penalty, rather than whether regularisation should be used at all.
| Approach | What controls the fitted surface? | Difference investigated here |
|---|---|---|
| Direct Dupire reconstruction | Derivatives of a fitted option-price surface | Reprice options through the PDE and optimise the volatility correction directly, avoiding explicit second differentiation of noisy market quotes. |
| Reference-centred H1/Tikhonov calibration | Correction magnitude and first derivatives | Add a spatial potential that changes the cost of departing from the reference across the domain. |
| Second-order/H2 smoothing | Higher-order derivative penalties | Compare a first-order Schrödinger-type energy with a second-order penalty in the same correction coordinates. |
| This project's full operator | Magnitude + directional smoothness + quote-density and wing potentials | Test whether the chosen spatial shrinkage helps beyond H1, H2 and their individual-potential variants. |
Reference-centred Tikhonov calibration has established predecessors, including Crépey (2003). The distinguishing hypothesis is the construction and use of the potentials within this shared calibration framework. The Schrödinger analogy alone does not establish mathematical novelty. Detailed literature positioning.
In quantum mechanics, a Schrödinger Hamiltonian combines a kinetic operator with a potential. Its quadratic energy balances variation in a function against the cost of its location. This project adapts that structure to the real-valued volatility correction. Hamiltonian background.
Let
With suitable boundary conditions, its associated differential operator has the Schrödinger form
- Kinetic/smoothness terms: discourage rapid changes across strikes and maturities.
-
Positive magnitude term
$\beta$ : penalises large corrections and supplies a positive lower bound for the discrete energy. -
Spatial potential
$V$ : makes departures from the reference more expensive in selected regions.
The implementation builds
The potential is bounded and nonnegative. It changes the spatial weighting within an H1-type energy; it does not create a higher Sobolev smoothness order. Energy equivalence and assumptions.
The model starts from an SSVI reference and fits a correction to log local variance:
Here
For
The workflow is:
- Fit the reference using training prices.
- Construct the potentials from training-quote locations and the declared wing rule.
- Build the operator matrix on nondimensional coordinates with consistent nodal and edge quadrature.
-
Calibrate with damped Gauss–Newton steps, backtracking and amplitude bounds. The normal equations include
$\lambda R/p$ in the curvature matrix and$-\lambda Rh/p$ on the right-hand side. - Select regularisation inside the training fold, including the unchanged reference as a candidate, then evaluate on withheld quotes or expiries.
The same reference, correction coordinates, price scales, PDE settings and optimisation budget are shared by the controlled comparisons. Density-only and wing-only variants test what each added component contributes. Exact benchmark workflow.
The useful stability question is: how much can the estimated correction move when the observed prices change slightly?
Fix the reference, interpolation, weights, regulariser and pricing linearisation. Let
Nonnegative potentials, positive quadrature weights and
Why: the difference equals
This result motivates the regularised Gauss–Newton systems used in the implementation. Its stated assumptions matter: it does not establish global Lipschitz continuity or uniqueness of the full nonlinear, refitted and tuned calibration procedure. Nor does stability alone imply lower estimation error—stronger shrinkage can add bias. Each comparison is also trace-normalised and tuned separately, so the added potential does not automatically improve its stability constant. Proof, risk decomposition and counterexample.
The study covers 50 outer folds. The table compares held-out pricing RMSE with the SSVI-based PDE baseline; lower RMSE means more accurate option prices.
| Data | What was withheld | Full operator's pricing error versus baseline |
|---|---|---|
| Euro Stoxx market options | Individual quotes | 34.18% lower |
| Euro Stoxx market options | Entire expiries | 46.81% higher |
| Author-supplied simulated Bates prices | Individual quotes | 75.30% lower |
| Author-supplied simulated Bates prices | Entire expiries | 75.44% lower |
On ten new noise draws with known volatility, the full operator won five times but had higher mean recovery error than SSVI: 0.09679 versus 0.04096. Some unstable fits dominate that average. The results support useful pricing gains in particular settings, while showing that the chosen quantum-inspired energy does not consistently recover the latent surface more accurately. Full H1/H2 comparisons and diagnostics.
The comparisons use finite optimisation budgets and many fits reached iteration limits. Market data provide no true local-volatility surface. Numerical quote weights are not measured bid–ask uncertainties, and the H1/H2 comparators are controlled adaptations rather than exact reproductions of each paper's implementation. These are calibration results; trading profitability is not evaluated.
| Component | Implementation |
|---|---|
| Density and wing potentials | potentials.py |
| Grid scaling and energy matrix | scaling.py |
| Tapered reference correction | reference_correction.py |
| PDE pricing and sensitivities | calibration_pde.py |
| Penalties, optimisation and nested comparison | literature_benchmark.py |
Saved tables and figures are browsable immediately. Python 3.12.14 was used for the audit. From the repository root:
python -m pip install -r requirements-audit.txt
python -m pytest -q
OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS=1 python scripts/23_literature_benchmarks.py --inputs data/literature/benchmark_inputs --jobs 6
OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS=1 python scripts/24_literature_diagnostics.py --stage outputs/stage_23_literature_audit_final --jobs 3
OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS=1 python scripts/25_parameter_grid_sensitivity.py
OPENBLAS_NUM_THREADS=1 python scripts/26_analyze_literature_results.pyThe full benchmark is computationally expensive. Input provenance and tests document the inputs and implementation checks. For archived arrays, extract calibration-arrays.zip at the repository root with python -m zipfile -e calibration-arrays.zip .; ARTIFACTS.json lists paths and hashes. Earlier outputs remain historical evidence, separate from the current audit. The archived Laplace module is outside this study.
Author: Fakhruddin Hakim Hussain · Portfolio
