Repository navigation
Description
What happened
PR #9 updated the grillme agent definition (grillme.md) and the grilling skill (SKILL.md) to require a **Recommended:** <answer and why> line on inline questions. The agent definition at lines 225-226 explicitly covers follow-up thread replies: "When the follow-up is itself a decision question, include **Recommended:** the same way as new comments." However, SKILL.md step 2 still reads: "Reply in-thread when an answer needs a follow-up" — with no mention of including a recommendation. The review agent flagged this as a low-severity internal consistency finding in run 32518019927, but the PR was merged without addressing it.
What could go better
The SKILL.md and grillme.md now diverge on follow-up reply behavior. While grillme.md is the primary runtime document and the risk is low, SKILL.md serves as the canonical behavior spec for the grilling skill. If another agent or a future refactor consumes the skill definition without the grillme.md agent definition, follow-up replies would lack recommendations. This is a high-confidence finding — the review agent identified the exact gap and suggested a specific fix. The only uncertainty is whether the author deliberately chose not to address it (considering it negligible) or simply missed it during a fast merge cycle.
Proposed change
In .fullsend/custom/skills/grilling/SKILL.md, update step 2 of the Turn model from:
- Resolve threads whose answers are satisfactory. Reply in-thread when an answer needs a follow-up. Leave unanswered threads alone.
To something like:
- Resolve threads whose answers are satisfactory. Reply in-thread when an answer needs a follow-up — when that follow-up is itself a decision question, include
**Recommended:** <answer and why>the same way as new comments. Leave unanswered threads alone.
This aligns SKILL.md with the instruction already present in grillme.md under "Rules for thread replies."
Validation criteria
After the change, SKILL.md step 2 and grillme.md's "Rules for thread replies" section should both mention including **Recommended:** on follow-up replies that are decision questions. Verify by grepping both files for Recommended — both should have matching coverage for new comments and follow-up replies.
Generated by retro agent from #9
Activity
fullsend-ai-triage commentedon Aug 21, 2026
🤖 Finished Triage · ✅ Success · Started 7:49 PM UTC · Completed 7:52 PM UTC
Commit:
aa08686· View workflow run →fullsend-ai-triage commentedon Aug 21, 2026
Confirmed the divergence:
grillme.mdlines under "Rules for thread replies" include the**Recommended:**instruction for follow-up decision questions, whileSKILL.mdstep 2 omits it.Proposed test case
Single-line text change in SKILL.md step 2. No code or workflow changes needed.
Next steps:
/fs-code— agent creates a PR to implement this issue/fs-code <your instruction>— agent implements with your specific guidancefullsend-ai-coder commentedon Aug 21, 2026
🤖 Finished Code · ✅ Success · Started 7:53 PM UTC · Completed 7:57 PM UTC
Commit:
aa08686· View workflow run →